Emails will be monitored but our phone lines will be unavailable. Orders will be dispatched where possible.
Comparing Above Ground
vs. Underground Heating
Oil Tanks
In the shift towards sustainable living, heating oil remains a pivotal resource for residential warmth and comfort across the UK, especially in areas lacking access to mains gas. This necessitates a crucial decision for homeowners: selecting the right type of heating oil storage.
With options including above-ground and underground tanks, each offers unique advantages tailored to different needs and premises.
Understanding Above Ground Heating Oil Tanks
Above ground heating oil tanks are usually the most popular choice for homeowners, offering a straightforward solution for oil storage. These tanks are typically constructed from robust materials, with durable steel bunded oil tanks or reliable plastic bunded oil tanks made from materials such as polyethylene, designed to withstand the elements and ensure long-term reliability.
Common types include single-skinned tanks, which are simple and cost-effective, and double-skinned or bunded oil tanks, which provide an extra layer of protection against leaks, making them a safer and more environmentally friendly option.
The key benefits of above ground tanks lie in their ease of installation and accessibility. Unlike their underground counterparts, these tanks do not require extensive excavation work, significantly reducing initial setup time and costs.
Maintenance and inspection are also more straightforward, as the tank's exterior and fittings are easily accessible for routine checks and cleaning. Additionally, the elevated position mitigates the risk of ground contamination in the event of a leak, aligning with both safety and environmental considerations.
Understanding Underground Heating Oil Tanks
Underground heating oil tanks present a discreet storage solution, primarily chosen for their minimal visual impact and efficient use of space. These tanks are typically constructed from heavy-duty materials such as fibreglass, steel, or a combination thereof, offering enhanced durability and resistance to corrosion.
The choice between single-walled and double-walled (bunded) designs depends on regulatory requirements and the homeowner's preference for additional environmental protection.
The principal advantage of underground tanks lies in their ability to blend seamlessly with the landscape, preserving the aesthetic appeal of a property and freeing up valuable garden or yard space. This option is particularly attractive for those seeking to maintain the uninterrupted visual appeal of their home environment. Moreover, by situating the tank below ground, the risk of accidental damage from vehicles or vandalism is reduced, adding a layer of security to the oil supply.
Installation Considerations
When it comes to installation, the processes for above-ground and underground heating oil tanks differ fairly significantly. As you might expect, above-ground heating oil tanks are usually far easier and less costly to install.
Without the need for excavation, above ground tanks can be positioned on a stable base or stand, making the setup process quicker and less costly than an underground installation. This accessibility not only simplifies the initial install, but also makes future relocation straight forward should the need arise.
Conversely, installing an underground tank involves a more complex and labour-intensive process. It requires excavation, adherence to strict safety and environmental regulations, and possibly the installation of protective barriers to prevent contamination of the surrounding soil.
While this process incurs higher upfront costs and preparation time, the long-term aesthetic and space-saving benefits can make it a worthwhile investment for some homeowners who need to prioritise the appearance of outdoor areas, or who do not have the space to accommodate an above-ground tank.
Balancing these factors and deciding where to position a heating oil tank is crucial in choosing the most suitable solution for each home.
Maintenance & Accessibility
Maintenance is a crucial aspect of ensuring the longevity and safety of heating oil tanks, with accessibility playing a significant role in the ease of this upkeep. Above-ground tanks inherently offer superior accessibility, making regular inspections, cleaning, and repairs less cumbersome.
This accessibility allows for more straightforward monitoring for leaks or corrosion, ensuring that any necessary maintenance can be promptly addressed without the need for specialised equipment or excavation.
Meanwhile, underground tanks often pose more challenges in terms of maintenance due to their concealed nature. Inspections may require specialist equipment to check for leaks or damage, and any repairs could necessitate partial excavation, leading to increased maintenance costs and complexity.
While underground tanks are designed to be robust and leak-resistant, particularly with advancements in materials and construction, the difficulty in accessing them can make routine maintenance a more intricate and potentially more costly endeavour. Therefore, the balance between aesthetic appeal and maintenance accessibility is a key consideration in the decision-making process for homeowners.
Safety & Environmental Concerns
Safety features and environmental considerations are paramount when choosing between above-ground and underground heating oil tanks.
Above-ground tanks have seen significant advancements in technology over the years, enhancing their safety and environmental protection measures. For example, the benefits of bunded tanks, which feature a tank within a tank design, include a greatly reduced risk of spills due to the additional layer of security they offer. Moreover, their visible and accessible nature of oil tanks that are positioned above ground enables quicker detection and remediation of any issues, minimising potential environmental damage.
Underground tanks, while less visible and potentially less susceptible to physical damage from external sources, carry the risk of unnoticed leaks, which can lead to soil and water contamination before detection.
Modern underground tanks are designed with robust materials and leak detection systems to mitigate these risks, but the potential for environmental impact remains a concern. The choice between tank types therefore involves a balance between the immediate visibility and accessibility of above ground tanks and the subtler, but potentially more complex, environmental safeguards required for underground tanks.
Longevity & Durability
The longevity and durability of heating oil tanks are influenced by their construction materials, installation quality, and environmental exposure. Above ground tanks, while accessible and easier to maintain, are exposed to the elements, which can lead to a shorter lifespan compared to underground tanks.
Factors such as sunlight, temperature fluctuations, and precipitation can affect their condition over time, potentially leading to corrosion or weathering, especially in steel tanks. To combat this, modern above ground tanks are made with corrosion-resistant materials and protective coatings to extend their durability, and can last for several decades when correctly maintained.
Underground tanks are shielded from direct environmental exposure, which can significantly enhance their longevity. The stable underground temperature and protection from the weather reduce the risk of corrosion and weather-related wear and tear.
Nonetheless, they are not immune to potential issues, such as soil moisture and the chemical composition of the ground, which can affect certain materials over time. Proper installation and materials suited for the specific environmental conditions are crucial for maximising the lifespan of underground tanks.
Both tank types require adherence to maintenance protocols to ensure their durability. Regular inspections and upkeep can mitigate the effects of weather and environmental factors, extending the operational life of the tank. The choice between above ground and underground tanks should consider these aspects, balancing the immediate and long-term considerations of durability, maintenance, and environmental conditions.
Cost Analysis
It's important to note that specific costs will vary based on location, the specific type and size of the tank, local regulations, and the chosen installation company.
Cost Type
Above Ground Heating Oil Tanks
Underground Heating Oil Tanks
Installation
-
Generally lower than for underground tanks due to the simplicity of the installation process.
-
Costs include the price of the tank itself, any necessary base or stand, and labour.
-
There's no need for excavation, significantly reducing initial expenses.
-
Higher due to the complexity of the installation process.
-
Costs including excavation, potential landscaping post-installation, and additional protective measures to prevent environmental contamination.
Maintenance
-
Tend to be lower and more predictable.
-
Accessible for regular inspections and maintenance without special equipment.
-
May require more frequent maintenance checks due to exposure to the elements.
-
While the tank itself may require less frequent maintenance checks due to its protected underground position, the complexity and cost of those checks can be higher.
-
Leak detection systems and corrosion protection measures may involve additional investment.
Long-term Expenses
-
Costs could arise from environmental damage due to leaks, especially if a bunded tank is not used.
-
Replacement costs might occur sooner than with underground tanks due to weather-related wear and tear.
-
Typically have a longer lifespan due to reduced exposure to the elements.
-
However, if a leak occurs, the environmental remediation costs can be significant.
-
Removal or replacement of an underground tank can be considerably expensive due to excavation costs.
Regulatory Compliance & Insurance Implications
The regulatory landscape and insurance implications are crucial elements in the decision-making process for installing heating oil tanks.
In the UK, both above and below ground options must comply with regulations regarding heating oil tanks, concerning their design, installation, maintenance, and inspection to mitigate environmental risks and ensure safety. These regulations can vary locally, but generally include requirements on tank construction, positioning, and secondary containment measures to prevent leaks and spills.
Above ground tanks, while easier to install and maintain, must adhere to specific standards regarding their placement to avoid fire risks and environmental contamination. The visibility of these tanks allows for easier compliance checks and adjustments. Insurance companies may look favourably on the ease of inspection and reduced risk of unnoticed leaks, potentially reflecting in lower premiums or simpler policy requirements.
Underground tanks may face stricter regulations due to their potential impact on the environment. Insurers might require more rigorous documentation of compliance and maintenance records for these installations, considering the higher remediation costs associated with underground leaks.
However, the challenges in ensuring regulatory compliance and securing insurance for underground tanks can be offset by their long-term benefits, provided that homeowners are diligent in their maintenance and record-keeping practices.
Aesthetic & Space Considerations
Aesthetic impact and space usage are significant considerations for homeowners when selecting a heating oil tank. Above-ground tanks, while practical and accessible, can have a considerable visual presence in a garden or yard, potentially detracting from the overall aesthetic appeal of a property.
However, innovations in tank design have led to the development of both slimline oil tanks and low-profile tanks, which are less obtrusive and can blend more seamlessly with the outdoor environment. These alternatives offer a compromise, providing the functional benefits of above-ground tanks while minimising their visual impact.
Underground tanks, on the other hand, excel in preserving the aesthetic appeal and usable space of a property. By being installed below ground, they are almost entirely out of sight, allowing homeowners to maintain the natural beauty of their landscape without the visual interruption of a tank.
This option is particularly appealing for those with limited outdoor space or for whom the visual appearance of their property is paramount.
While underground tanks maximise space and aesthetics, the choice of tank type may also depend on the specific layout and size of the property, as well as the homeowner's priorities. Slimline and low-profile above-ground tanks can be an excellent solution for those with space constraints, offering a visually less intrusive option while still providing the ease of access and maintenance associated with above-ground tanks.
Making the Right Choice for Your Home
Choosing the right heating oil tank for your home requires a careful evaluation of your specific needs, preferences, and the constraints of your property. There are several key considerations to help guide you in making an informed decision:
Space Availability
Assess the available space on your property. If space is at a premium, an underground or slimline tank might be preferable to preserve your garden or yard aesthetics and usability. However, if you have ample outdoor space, a larger above ground tank could be more practical and cost-effective.
Aesthetic Preferences
Consider how important the visual impact of a tank is to you. If maintaining the aesthetic appeal of your property is a priority, underground tanks offer an out-of-sight solution. Alternatively, slimline and low-profile above ground tanks can minimise visual intrusion while still being easier to access for maintenance.
Budget Constraints
Analyse your budget for both the short-term installation costs and long-term maintenance. Above ground tanks typically offer a lower initial outlay and simpler, less costly maintenance. In contrast, underground tanks are usually more expensive to install, may be more expensive to insure, and may require more specialist maintenance and checks.
Safety and Environmental Concerns
Evaluate the safety features and environmental implications of each tank type. Consider advancements in tank technology that might mitigate risks, such as double-walled or bunded tanks, and assess how each option aligns with your environmental values and safety requirements.
Regulatory Compliance
Familiarise yourself with applicable regulations regarding heating oil storage to ensure any tank you consider will be compliant. This may influence your choice depending on the complexity and cost of meeting these requirements for above ground vs. underground tanks.
Insurance Implications
Check with your insurance provider to understand how your choice of tank might affect your premiums or coverage, particularly in terms of liability for environmental damage.
Find The Right Oil Storage Solution For Your Property
Whether you’re replacing an existing tank or planning a new installation, at Northern Tank Store we manufacture and supply a wide range of solutions to suit almost all types of property. We offer heating oil tanks in a full range of capacities on both plastic and steel construction, as well as all the heating oil accessories you may need for your system.
Our tanks are engineered to deliver many years of service, and ensure you can remain compliant with all relevant regulations. If you’re unsure which type of tank is best for you, our team is on hand to offer expert advice and information. With decades of industry experience, we can help you find exactly the right heating oil storage solution for your needs.
Explore our extensive range online, or contact us for tailored advice. Your perfect heating oil tank awaits.